Really stupid coughing question

chipper28

New member
So, I've been playing around with my cough ever since reading Amy's post on coughing this weekend (Thanks Amy by the way!!!). I'm not sure if I'm doing right, but I've been trying it every fifteen minutes or so at work all day today and I was just asked by one of my support staff if I was sick because "that cough sounds wet", so perhaps I am making progress!

My stupid question is: how can you tell where stuff is coming from? After a few of these coughs I've noticed a glob of slime on the roof of my mouth, but I think this might have just come from my throat and not really my lungs? I can normally tell if it came out of my sinuses, but I don't know how to distinguish between lungs and my throat. For a cough to be productive, do I need to be pulling up hunks the size of marbles like come out of sinuses, or are smaller little bits like pea-size also considered sputum production? Any way to tell whether sputum in the throat that you pull up is from sinus stuff that you swallowed or lung stuff that you coughed up?

I've never paid much attention to my lungs previously, because the only time I've had problems was when I had raging sinus infections and so I've always thought of lower respiratory infections as side effects and haven't really concentrated. Only time I've paid attention to how I coughed was when I'd done it so much that I had costacondritis (no idea how to spell that), so this whole concept is pretty new.

Thanks!
 

chipper28

New member
So, I've been playing around with my cough ever since reading Amy's post on coughing this weekend (Thanks Amy by the way!!!). I'm not sure if I'm doing right, but I've been trying it every fifteen minutes or so at work all day today and I was just asked by one of my support staff if I was sick because "that cough sounds wet", so perhaps I am making progress!

My stupid question is: how can you tell where stuff is coming from? After a few of these coughs I've noticed a glob of slime on the roof of my mouth, but I think this might have just come from my throat and not really my lungs? I can normally tell if it came out of my sinuses, but I don't know how to distinguish between lungs and my throat. For a cough to be productive, do I need to be pulling up hunks the size of marbles like come out of sinuses, or are smaller little bits like pea-size also considered sputum production? Any way to tell whether sputum in the throat that you pull up is from sinus stuff that you swallowed or lung stuff that you coughed up?

I've never paid much attention to my lungs previously, because the only time I've had problems was when I had raging sinus infections and so I've always thought of lower respiratory infections as side effects and haven't really concentrated. Only time I've paid attention to how I coughed was when I'd done it so much that I had costacondritis (no idea how to spell that), so this whole concept is pretty new.

Thanks!
 

chipper28

New member
So, I've been playing around with my cough ever since reading Amy's post on coughing this weekend (Thanks Amy by the way!!!). I'm not sure if I'm doing right, but I've been trying it every fifteen minutes or so at work all day today and I was just asked by one of my support staff if I was sick because "that cough sounds wet", so perhaps I am making progress!

My stupid question is: how can you tell where stuff is coming from? After a few of these coughs I've noticed a glob of slime on the roof of my mouth, but I think this might have just come from my throat and not really my lungs? I can normally tell if it came out of my sinuses, but I don't know how to distinguish between lungs and my throat. For a cough to be productive, do I need to be pulling up hunks the size of marbles like come out of sinuses, or are smaller little bits like pea-size also considered sputum production? Any way to tell whether sputum in the throat that you pull up is from sinus stuff that you swallowed or lung stuff that you coughed up?

I've never paid much attention to my lungs previously, because the only time I've had problems was when I had raging sinus infections and so I've always thought of lower respiratory infections as side effects and haven't really concentrated. Only time I've paid attention to how I coughed was when I'd done it so much that I had costacondritis (no idea how to spell that), so this whole concept is pretty new.

Thanks!
 

Diane

New member
Im not really sure there is a "science" to it, but as long as you are getting the stuff out, GOOD GOING !! Who cares where it is coming from as long as it keeps coming out....lol <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0"><img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">
 

Diane

New member
Im not really sure there is a "science" to it, but as long as you are getting the stuff out, GOOD GOING !! Who cares where it is coming from as long as it keeps coming out....lol <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0"><img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">
 

Diane

New member
Im not really sure there is a "science" to it, but as long as you are getting the stuff out, GOOD GOING !! Who cares where it is coming from as long as it keeps coming out....lol <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0"><img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">
 

Scarlett81

New member
Wow, good question. I wish there was more of a science to it, like we had instruction on what certain sputum looks like.
The only time I can ever tell that is in the morning, if I feel a crackle/plug-I'll huff and huff, cough, make myself wheeze deeply till I get that plug out, and then I can tell what the plug is once its out, therefore I know where it came from. I'd also say that I think I have a "stickier" side-my left lobe. Mucus from there tends to be more greenish.
I guess we all have our own tricks to read our own bodies that we learn over time.
 

Scarlett81

New member
Wow, good question. I wish there was more of a science to it, like we had instruction on what certain sputum looks like.
The only time I can ever tell that is in the morning, if I feel a crackle/plug-I'll huff and huff, cough, make myself wheeze deeply till I get that plug out, and then I can tell what the plug is once its out, therefore I know where it came from. I'd also say that I think I have a "stickier" side-my left lobe. Mucus from there tends to be more greenish.
I guess we all have our own tricks to read our own bodies that we learn over time.
 

Scarlett81

New member
Wow, good question. I wish there was more of a science to it, like we had instruction on what certain sputum looks like.
The only time I can ever tell that is in the morning, if I feel a crackle/plug-I'll huff and huff, cough, make myself wheeze deeply till I get that plug out, and then I can tell what the plug is once its out, therefore I know where it came from. I'd also say that I think I have a "stickier" side-my left lobe. Mucus from there tends to be more greenish.
I guess we all have our own tricks to read our own bodies that we learn over time.
 
Top