Choosing a Center - CHOP vs duPont

hmw

New member
This is the data reported to the CFF Registry for the pediatric care centers you are considering and/or being discussed in this thread for the year 2008 (most recent year available):
<br />
<br /><b>CHOP</b> ...this is a transplant center so will get sicker patients.
<br />fev1: 100%
<br />bmi: 54.8%
<br />guidelines of care: 60.3%
<br />
<br /><b>Hopkins</b> ...also a transplant center.
<br />fev1: 88.3%
<br />bmi: 49%
<br />guidelines of care: 73.7%
<br />
<br /><b>DuPont</b>
<br />fev1: 87.4%
<br />bmi: 48.4%
<br />guidelines of care: 42.9%
<br />
<br /><b>UNC</b> ...also a transplant center
<br />fev1: 89.6
<br />bmi: 43.9%
<br />guidelines of care: 86.2%
<br />
<br /><b>National Average</b>
<br />fev1: 90.2%
<br />bmi: 48.4%
<br />guidelines of care: 68.6%
<br />
<br />This data doesn't tell the whole story of how these centers add up. However, it's valuable to know; a reflection of the average health of the children that receive their care there.
<br />
<br />Our center director has told me that Hopkins has an interest in 'rare mutation' cases. Our family's circumstances w/my daughter having an unknown mutation and my son's status being unknown for quite a long time warranted a discussion about this. We've also seen here that CHOP does not seem quite as open-minded to 'atypical' cases or rare mutations; but they have an extremely good program overall... your experience will vary based on your child's individual circumstances perhaps.
<br />
<br />You can access all of these statistics yourself on cff.org website using the link for care center data (you'll have to register as a user for the site if you haven't yet.)
 

KAC1210

New member
Hi there! Sorry you are having a hard time with this. We go to A. I. Dupont. I absolutely love them. What doctor do you see at A. I. We see Dr. Heinle and I think he is great. I have never felt like he didnt't know what he was doing. I have never second guessed what he says. I have, however, had to bring Trevor in for sick visits and had his doctor not be there. I didn't care too much for any of the other doctors and think that if I was stuck with them I would worried. When I had to be with some of them, they just never felt like they were sure. This last time we were admitted, he just needed albuterol treatments every two hours. Dr. King kept asking me if he has had all his vaccines. She kept makin me feel like she thought it was purtussis. He was not even coughing! So you have to do what you feel is right for you. I am very happy with Dr. Heinle and am very glad I got him.
 

KAC1210

New member
Hi there! Sorry you are having a hard time with this. We go to A. I. Dupont. I absolutely love them. What doctor do you see at A. I. We see Dr. Heinle and I think he is great. I have never felt like he didnt't know what he was doing. I have never second guessed what he says. I have, however, had to bring Trevor in for sick visits and had his doctor not be there. I didn't care too much for any of the other doctors and think that if I was stuck with them I would worried. When I had to be with some of them, they just never felt like they were sure. This last time we were admitted, he just needed albuterol treatments every two hours. Dr. King kept asking me if he has had all his vaccines. She kept makin me feel like she thought it was purtussis. He was not even coughing! So you have to do what you feel is right for you. I am very happy with Dr. Heinle and am very glad I got him.
 

KAC1210

New member
Hi there! Sorry you are having a hard time with this. We go to A. I. Dupont. I absolutely love them. What doctor do you see at A. I. We see Dr. Heinle and I think he is great. I have never felt like he didnt't know what he was doing. I have never second guessed what he says. I have, however, had to bring Trevor in for sick visits and had his doctor not be there. I didn't care too much for any of the other doctors and think that if I was stuck with them I would worried. When I had to be with some of them, they just never felt like they were sure. This last time we were admitted, he just needed albuterol treatments every two hours. Dr. King kept asking me if he has had all his vaccines. She kept makin me feel like she thought it was purtussis. He was not even coughing! So you have to do what you feel is right for you. I am very happy with Dr. Heinle and am very glad I got him.
 

antonette1279

New member
I am just throwing this in there but I love Dr. Dovey over at St. Christophers children's special care hospital...he is great as a doctor...great the way he explains things and most of all great with the kids!!!
 

antonette1279

New member
I am just throwing this in there but I love Dr. Dovey over at St. Christophers children's special care hospital...he is great as a doctor...great the way he explains things and most of all great with the kids!!!
 

antonette1279

New member
I am just throwing this in there but I love Dr. Dovey over at St. Christophers children's special care hospital...he is great as a doctor...great the way he explains things and most of all great with the kids!!!
 

LouLou

New member
I think CHOP is great. The older I get the more I want to support programs that are in the know about cf research so myself and my son are top of mind when advancements are made. Also, just hearing about them gives me hope. CHOP is a big research hospital. I live in CT and travel to CHOP every 8 weeks to participate in V770 trial at CHOP.

My son was found to have two mutations of the cf gene through CHOP. I think its typical to consider benign mutations just that benign but I do agree CHOP should have met the patient and find that unusual that if he did have pulmonary symptoms he was not given a consult to steer him in the right direction for care.

If I moved to the Philly area I'd send my son back to CHOP care in a heartbeat. I'm happy to have CHOP as part of my care plan and think they are ahead of the curve for sure! Now HUP (the adult program) is another story for another time....
 

LouLou

New member
I think CHOP is great. The older I get the more I want to support programs that are in the know about cf research so myself and my son are top of mind when advancements are made. Also, just hearing about them gives me hope. CHOP is a big research hospital. I live in CT and travel to CHOP every 8 weeks to participate in V770 trial at CHOP.

My son was found to have two mutations of the cf gene through CHOP. I think its typical to consider benign mutations just that benign but I do agree CHOP should have met the patient and find that unusual that if he did have pulmonary symptoms he was not given a consult to steer him in the right direction for care.

If I moved to the Philly area I'd send my son back to CHOP care in a heartbeat. I'm happy to have CHOP as part of my care plan and think they are ahead of the curve for sure! Now HUP (the adult program) is another story for another time....
 

LouLou

New member
I think CHOP is great. The older I get the more I want to support programs that are in the know about cf research so myself and my son are top of mind when advancements are made. Also, just hearing about them gives me hope. CHOP is a big research hospital. I live in CT and travel to CHOP every 8 weeks to participate in V770 trial at CHOP.
<br />
<br />My son was found to have two mutations of the cf gene through CHOP. I think its typical to consider benign mutations just that benign but I do agree CHOP should have met the patient and find that unusual that if he did have pulmonary symptoms he was not given a consult to steer him in the right direction for care.
<br />
<br />If I moved to the Philly area I'd send my son back to CHOP care in a heartbeat. I'm happy to have CHOP as part of my care plan and think they are ahead of the curve for sure! Now HUP (the adult program) is another story for another time....
 

LouLou

New member
oh and by the way, my son would be considered CRMS (the latest term or atypical as I believe that term is out of vogue:) The only reason he was tested extensively is because I have cf. They found a 2nd mutation which is assoc w/ PS and mild pulmonary involvement. Both CHOP and all other future care have treated him agressively as they would any other cf patient which is what we want. I don't want him treated different because in the long run I know cf can become pretty darn typical very fast. Prevention is key!
 

LouLou

New member
oh and by the way, my son would be considered CRMS (the latest term or atypical as I believe that term is out of vogue:) The only reason he was tested extensively is because I have cf. They found a 2nd mutation which is assoc w/ PS and mild pulmonary involvement. Both CHOP and all other future care have treated him agressively as they would any other cf patient which is what we want. I don't want him treated different because in the long run I know cf can become pretty darn typical very fast. Prevention is key!
 

LouLou

New member
oh and by the way, my son would be considered CRMS (the latest term or atypical as I believe that term is out of vogue:) The only reason he was tested extensively is because I have cf. They found a 2nd mutation which is assoc w/ PS and mild pulmonary involvement. Both CHOP and all other future care have treated him agressively as they would any other cf patient which is what we want. I don't want him treated different because in the long run I know cf can become pretty darn typical very fast. Prevention is key!
 

mjsmama

New member
Just wanted to add that we are extremely happy with CHOP. Everyone we see has such a great, caring attitude with our son, including Dr. Suzanne Beck, Jaime & Dave from PT, Nurses Kerri and Lauren. We feel that they are on top of new therapies/meds/situations and respond to our questions/concerns with care.
 

mjsmama

New member
Just wanted to add that we are extremely happy with CHOP. Everyone we see has such a great, caring attitude with our son, including Dr. Suzanne Beck, Jaime & Dave from PT, Nurses Kerri and Lauren. We feel that they are on top of new therapies/meds/situations and respond to our questions/concerns with care.
 

mjsmama

New member
Just wanted to add that we are extremely happy with CHOP. Everyone we see has such a great, caring attitude with our son, including Dr. Suzanne Beck, Jaime & Dave from PT, Nurses Kerri and Lauren. We feel that they are on top of new therapies/meds/situations and respond to our questions/concerns with care.
 
Top