Sakem, I don't think she was going as far as you imply (ie death). She was just expressing the fact that CF is not nice, and if your child has CF it is just as much a disservice for us to pretend it is not as bad as it is as it would be to go too far.
I tend to be slow to respond to the newly diagnosed as I chose to raise a child with CF, and with signficant complications so I didn't have the moment in time when someone had to tell me my child had CF.
My thoughts are pretty simple:
1) If you come and your child (or you) has chronic colds, GI issues, etc that might be CF and you are looking for more info: we should be gentle and helpful
2) if they have signs/symptoms that are LIKELY CF (based upon the collective knowledge of the users here) then again temper, but help them to start to understand what it means to live with CF.
3) if they come because the child has been dx'd with CF, then while tact is warranted, their life is already shaken, be polite but honest. There is no reason to use kid gloves, CF is a nasty disease and there is very little 'pretty' about it. This sucks, it hurts, it devastates, but not being honest is not helping anyone.
As for those on the board with 'miracle stories', yes there are cases of cystics living to 60+, cases of ones w/ atypical CF that have few if any issues, cases of people that go years between abx; but this is not reality.
In my opinion (and I'm sure many will disagree) the most helpful posts would be ones about how to live with what life has dealt and what to prepare for; not how to avoid the reality of it.