I feel exactly the same as you, Ethan. You have a great deal of pride as I do. There is no doubt this country is stressed to the max with social programs and giveaways to those who have not earned those entitlements. Currently we sit on a bubble of $17 trillion in debt so we all know where it's going. $22 trillion is the cap and quantitative easing will not last for ever. Even the UK is now employing QE. It's very concerning and won't end well, globally. There are so many in this country, undeserving of an entitlements, yet there are all sorts of people, as you mention, with cancer, crohn's, kidney failure, diabetes, back pain and many other ailments that are costing them money and they need help. And like you, I can't stand the thought of a handout. I would rather be employed and stand on my own two feet. But just as you, I consider my future self and what might happen to me, family, etc., should all else fail.
Your statement is very noble and selfless about taking assistance while others struggle. I feel the same way about taking any assistance, even from PARC, for example. Should I ever need it, I can't take it because I think of all those little CF patients and their families who are in much greater need from a finite source. It would be selfish of me to take a handout when those younger folks need a shot at life. I had my shot. So yes, I understand how you feel.
I only maintain that should we ever need SSDI/Medicare, it should be easier to access or at least a given. Unfortunately CF is a degenerative disease so we are all in a collision course with SSDI/Medicare. It's inevitable. And when we cross that threshold, that's when the nightmare begins. The waiting, the wondering, the stress, the deterioration of health. Even the fear of death. Perhaps a modest percentage of patients but it grows as we all live longer. Statistically, I'm way past my expiration date but I've been very lucky...so far. However, I know what's coming. At that moment of decision, we all ponder the quality of life, with few options.
And you are right. Establishment republicans will dig in, as well as libertarians. Ultimately it's all about money, left and right and money talks. When I we see a large potential voting block apparently being given some form of amnesty, as well as a free hand out like health care coverage, Medicare, etc...everyone is fighting much harder for a smaller piece of the pie. To that degree, suddenly I don't feel so selfish proposing CF as a disability.
As you say, "It takes passionate people to move the status quo." Well, I'm passionate as you, Believing and Autumn are passionate. There are many other CF patients and families as passionate, given the Facebook response. It's just the tip of the iceberg but we have to speak up. I'm sure there are many pitfalls and caveats to this issue. But as I said, I'm just the kid in the room asking "why not" in a room full of adults saying, "what for". Perhaps we all can continue the conversation and convince the powers at CFF why it matters. Only then, they can tell us why or why not. But we have to try to lobby for change.
No politician would look in the eyes of a CF child and say, "you don't deserve to live". So why indicate the opposite to CF adults? We deserve to live as well.
I appreciate your passion, Ethan. You have family to live for. That is a great responsibility for a CF patient. I applaud you. Let's keep it going. Maybe something positive will happen.
Randford, 52 w/CF
I do fundamentally worry about the cost of social programs (even the ones that benefit me) and that eventually the country won't be able to fund everyone we have committed to help. Also I look around me and see that it isn't just CF patients that are fighting the 'other half of the battle'. I have neighbors with cancer, chron's, kidney failure, diabetes, back pain and many other ailments that are costing them money, health, and comfort. I have neighbors in good health that can't find jobs, or have family cause financial problems. I just can't see how I ask for money for myself (or even my future self), when I'm making it by better than many of my neighbors. Somehow it feels hypocritical.
Aside: Randford and Believing I completely appreciate your passion in this topic. It takes passionate people to move the status quo. Autumn's posting about real people and the real problems they face (like Mike's story) is very persuasive. I appreciate that you are working to understand someone with different thinking (doing so will probably help you develop even stronger arguments). And I'm softer on my position than I was when I joined this forum. Even if you can find consensus with a RINO like me, you will still have a way to go to develop an argument strong enough to move a more ideological pure Republican or Libertarian. Keep at it, if you don't move them all the way to your position, maybe you could move them to a position like mine
.