Daughter considering marriage/having kids with CF carrier

anonymous

New member
I hope we don't upset everyone, but we are scared to death of our daughter becoming pregnant by her fiance' who has a family history of CF. His brother died last year at age 20 from CF, and has a second brother 22 that also has CF. According to the fiance', he doesn't know if he has CF which strikes us as extremely insane to not know particuarly since both of his brothers are CF positive and one already died young (please feel free to comment on that "I don't know if I've got it" position of the fiance').

We don't know much of anything about this (we're ignorant of all the facts about CF) other than it appears that based on what we've read so far, that reproducing may be hazardous to the extreme for their offspring.

Are we nuts? Over reacting? Or should we be afraid and suggest testing of our both and if positive for CF, pay for sterilization?

Name withheld so as not to be ID'd by relatives of the other family.

(Zip - flame suit on)
 

JennifersHope

New member
Hi,

My name is Jennifer I am 33 w CF and a bunch of other things.. From the sound of your post, it looks l as if you are overreacting, like many parents do when they FEEL the need to protect their child.. Thing is, you don't really need to freak out, Even if your daughters future husband does have CF, you daughter needs to be a carrier of CF as well for the child to get it, and even then, if she is.. it doesn't mean for sure the child would have CF. If you want accurate information go to CFF.org . I think the chances are if both parents are a carrier that the child has a 1 in 4 chance of getting CF.

The feel free to coment on this guy not knowing if he has CF.. I am not going to make a comment on that. other then to say that maybe he is afraid to tell you the truth about it though because maybe he is afraid you are going to freak out and not want your daughter with him.. I am just guessing here though..
I have to say from the post it comes across to me like you don't like him. I could be misreading your post..I didn't know I had CF till I was 29. I am sure he has been tested though if both his brothers have it... but either way....If he does have CF then You would most likely not have to pay for sterilaztion procedures to be done because almost all men with CF don't have Vas Deferens and they can't get a women pregnant without having special procedures done.

If he is just a carrier, and you daughter is worried about having a child with CF, she can get tested to see if she is a carrier as well. I understand that you are worried..but don't jump the gun...This poor guy has lost his brother to CF and has been through enough, he doesn't need his inlaws to freak out on him. I am sure if your daughter is old enough to get married, she is old enough to educate herself on this topic and make her own choices in life...and just so you know because you said you didn't know anything about CF.. not everyone dies young with it, not everyone has a horrible life. and even though I have CF I don't feel as if I have was a hazard to the extreme.. (well normally I don't)



Good luck..

Jennifer
 

anonymous

New member
I understand your worry. I dont know why the fiance would not know if he has CF- he should be tested of course. Does he have any symptoms? If he doesnt have it then he needs to know if he is a carrier and if he is but your daughter is not then their children would not get CF but could be carriers also. Of course there is a possibility that he is not a carrier. They need to get genetic counseling and both be tested. Susan
 

Allie

New member
Your daughter and he BOTH need to be tested as carriers. I'm assuming he would know by now if he had CF, being as his brother died of the disease. My husband had CF, and his brother was tested right away for it. Luckily, he's only a carrier.

If they do both turn out to be carriers, it's their choice, many people have strong opinions on this topic, but all you can do is talk to them. Keep the lines of communication open.

Any other questions, feel free to email me. My address is in my profile.
 

anonymous

New member
Thanx for the responses. Admittedly, we're not terribly fond of the guy but not because of CF. CF only came to light when his brother passed away. It was then that we found out about the family history which was not the best way to learn of it (imho). He has not been tested for carrying CF. Being the over-protective (lol) parents/in-laws we have found genetic screening md to accomplish.

Any suggestions on how to nudge them into genetic testing (other that the obvious ones to us)?

Fiance' is kind of a free loader / medically uninsured meaning we'll end up paying for his roulette wheel approach if their child has CF - along with extreme heartache and the potential that we as grandparents may, by design and their choice, outlive our grandchildren. That SUCKS!

We don't want to make our daughter hate us, but honestly feel like we have a real problem with a lackadasial approach to this situation (which they both have). Since this is definitely all new to us, how should we nudge them into genetic testing? Our daughter has a trust account with significant $$$'s in it and we were considering threatening to stop applying annual deposits unless they are both tested, and if carriers, that fiance' be sterilized. If indeed they are both carriers, we do not consider a 25% chance of CF acceptable odds (sorry, that's truly how we feel).
 

Allie

New member
email me, I'll have to get back to you a little later, but I might be able to help you talk to your daughter.
 

rose4cale

New member
I just want to say that I hope you are NOT using CF as an excuse for your daughter not to marry this guy. That is wrong. It sounds to me you are more worried about your assets and your daughters financial well being. And if my in-laws were to imply that we should be sterile as so we don't reproduce another CF child...I would be extremely offended!!!
 
Well, I had no idea I was a carrier and no idea that my son's father was a carrier. I had never even heard of CF. Ray, Austin's dad, swears that there is no one with CF on his side of the family and there are no family members on my side that have CF either. I'm sure there is someone among all those family members that have CF or carry the gene, we just don't know WHO. We cannot and will not lay blame.

I agree that it's your daughter's choice but I also feel your pain. Austin is almost 17 and if he ever decides to try and have children, they will have to do some genetic testing. He will most likely be sterile and if they find that to be the case, it will be their choice whether or not they want to take further measures to try and have a baby on their own or adopt.
 

julie

New member
I'm going to answer you questions in caps, so please don't feel that I am "yelling" by using the caps.

hope we don't upset everyone, but we are scared to death of our daughter becoming pregnant by her fiance' who has a family history of CF. His brother died last year at age 20 from CF, and has a second brother 22 that also has CF. According to the fiance', he doesn't know if he has CF which strikes us as extremely insane to not know particuarly since both of his brothers are CF positive and one already died young (please feel free to comment on that "I don't know if I've got it" position of the fiance').
MY HUSBAND'S BROTHER DIDN'T FIND OUT IF HE WAS A CARRIER OR NOT UNTIL AFTER HIS GIRLFRIEND WAS PREGNANT WITH THEIR SON. YOU ARE RIGHT, THIS ISN'T THE BEST WAY TO GO ON HIS PART BUT THE REALITY OF THE SUITUATION IS YOU CAN'T EVER CONTROL OTHERS BUT RATHER GUIDE THEM IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION.

We don't know much of anything about this (we're ignorant of all the facts about CF) other than it appears that based on what we've read so far, that reproducing may be hazardous to the extreme for their offspring.
BOTH PARTNERS MUST BE CARRIERS OF THE CF GENE TO PASS IT ON TO THEIR HCILD. I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND THAT YOUR DAUGHTER AND HER FIANCE GET TESTED. IF HER FIANCE'S BROTHERS HAD THE SAME MOM AND DAD, HIS MUTATIONS WILL BE THE SAME AS THEIRS (1 OF THEIR 2 MUTATIONS) IF HE IS A CARRIER. TO BE SAFE, YOUR DAUGHTER SHOULD HAVE AN EXPANDED MUTATION TEST DONE BY QUEST DIAGNOSTICS SIMPLY BECAUSE HE HAS A FAMILY HISTORY OF CF.

Are we nuts? Over reacting? Or should we be afraid and suggest testing of our both and if positive for CF, pay for sterilization?
NO YOU AREN'T NUTS NOR ARE YOU OVERREACTING, IF BOTH TEST POSITIVE FOR CF CARRIERS THERE ARE A FEW THINGS THAT CAN BE DONE. IF THEY DO WANT CHILDREN, IN-VITRO FERTILIZATION WITH PRE-GENETIC IMPLANTATION DIAGNOSIS IS AN OPTION. STERILIZATION IS ALSO ALWAYS AN OPTION, BUT A TAD EXTREME IF THEY EVER WANT CHILDREN.

Name withheld so as not to be ID'd by relatives of the other family.
IF YOU HAVE MORE QUESTIONS AND STILL WANT TO REMAIN ANNON. PLEASE FEEL FREE TO EMAIL ME, division902@hotmail.com ANY TIME WITH QUESTIONS,CONCERNS. I AM HAPPY TO HELP OUT.

Thanx for the responses. Admittedly, we're not terribly fond of the guy but not because of CF. CF only came to light when his brother passed away. It was then that we found out about the family history which was not the best way to learn of it (imho). He has not been tested for carrying CF. Being the over-protective (lol) parents/in-laws we have found genetic screening md to accomplish.
CLEARLY THERE ARE SOME UNDERLYING ISSUES THAT SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TO YOUR DAUGHTER INITIALLY, AND PRIVATELY. ONLY AT A LATER DATE SHOULD YOU SPEAK TO BOTH OF THEM SO THEY DON'T FEEL ATTACKED. DISCUSS IT WITH HER FIRST, GIVE YOUR DAUGHTER A CHANCE TO EXPLAIN HER POSITION. MAYBE THEY'VE ALREADY TALKED ABOUT IT. MAYBE SHE IS VERY UNEDUCATED ABOUT CF AND NEEDS A VISIT TO THIS SITE....

Any suggestions on how to nudge them into genetic testing (other that the obvious ones to us)?
TALK TO THEM, SHOW THEM THE FACTS, EXPLAIN THE PROBABILITIES OF THEM ENDING UP WITH A CHILD WITH CF, THE COMPLICATIONS AND COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH CF CARE (FEEL FREE TO GUIDE THEM TO THIS SITE SO THEY CAN ASK QUESTIONS FOR THEMSELVES).

Fiance' is kind of a free loader / medically uninsured meaning we'll end up paying for his roulette wheel approach if their child has CF - along with extreme heartache and the potential that we as grandparents may, by design and their choice, outlive our grandchildren. That SUCKS!
SOUNDS LIKE YOU NEED A SERIOUS HEART TO HEART WITH YOUR DAUGHTER. MAKE IT ABOUT HER WELL BEING, HER FUTURE, HER FINANCIAL STABILITY AND YOUR CONCERNS FOR HER. DON'T MAKE IT ABOUT WHAT SHE ISN'T DOING RIGHT AND SO ON. I'M NOT TRYING TO BE JUDGEMENTAL OR ASSUME THIS IS THE WAY YOU WILL APPROACH IT, BUT FROM MANY POINTLESS CONVERSATIONS WITH MY MOTHER WHICH BEGAN IN THIS MANNER.... THEY NEVER GOT ANY OF US ANYWHERE!

We don't want to make our daughter hate us, but honestly feel like we have a real problem with a lackadasial approach to this situation (which they both have). Since this is definitely all new to us, how should we nudge them into genetic testing? Our daughter has a trust account with significant $$$'s in it and we were considering threatening to stop applying annual deposits unless they are both tested, and if carriers, that fiance' be sterilized. If indeed they are both carriers, we do not consider a 25% chance of CF acceptable odds (sorry, that's truly how we feel).
THE WHOLE THING IS A VERY SENSITIVE SUBJECT TO EVEN THE MOST LEVELHEADED OF PEOPLE, AND IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE THE FIANCE IS SUCH. MONEY IS NEVER A WAY TO "HOLD A PERSON HOSTAGE" BUT OFFER A COMPRIMISE AND MAKE SURE YOU EXPLAIN YOUR CONCERNS FOR THE SITUATION. AS I MENTIONED ABOVE, GUIDE THEM TO THIS SITE, BUY THEM A BOOK ON CF, ASK YOUR DAUGHTER TO TALK TO HER FIANCES PARENTS ABOUT THEIR SONS DEATH AND THE PAIN OF THAT (I.E. IF SHE ISN'T CAUTIOUS/DETERMINES HER AND HIS CARRIER STATUS THEY MAY BE IN THE SAME SITUATION SOMEDAY). I DO THINK IT'S REASONABLE TO STOP APPLYING ANNUAL DEPOSITS UNLESS THEY GET TESTED. THE STERILIZATION THING THOUGH.... MAYBE A BIT FAR. THERE IS ALWAYS AN IUD THAT IS ON OF THE ABSOLUTE MOST EFFECTIVE BIRTH CONTROL METHODS. IF THEY ARE BOTH CARIERS AND BY THE GRACE OF GOD (OR WHATEVER YOU BELIEVE IN) THEY DECIDE TO GO AHEAD WITH STERILIZATION, AT LEAST HAVE HER FIANCEE CYROPRESERVE AN AMPLE AMOUNT OF HIS SPERM. THAT WAY IN THE FUTURE, IF/WHEN THEY WANT BABIES, THEY CAN DO IVF WITH PGD AND AVOID CF ALL TOGETHER.

PLEASE FEEL FREE TO ASK MORE QUESTIONS AS YOU NEED TO, AND ALSO, PLEASE FEEL FREE TO EMAIL ME IF YOU WISH TO DO SO, division902@hotmail.com
 

miesl

New member
I'm going to sit squarely in the "You're seriously over-reacting" camp.

A) It's not your life.

B) They are getting MARRIED, not setting up a breeding camp. Chill.

C) I'm sure that given the situation, they will WANT to be tested eventually. You don't need to be so freakin' pushy.

D) To insist on having HIM sterilized is absolutely disgusting. You should be ashamed of yourselves - see point a) it's not your life.

E) If your daughter isn't even a carrier (which is the case 24 out of 25 cases) - you're having a serious freak-out over NOTHING.

Really, get a grip. This isn't the end of the world.

-Michelle (who is getting married in 9 months to Jeremy, 28 with CF, with all kinds of blessings from my family)
 

anonymous

New member
Though CF is a roulette wheel, and if by some unfortunate genetic chance your grandchild did have CF, you just don't know what color you'll land on - you might hit big and have kid with a mild case. Why would you, as grandparetns have to pay for this hypothetical child's expenses? Is this just a money issue? Some people with Cf do indeed have realtively normal and expense free lives - Cf costs me on average 100$ a year (I do have good insurance - but I also am mild enough not to need a lot of meds) - seriously. I am sure I am on the low end of the spectrum, but the point is that it is indeed a spectrum and you just don't know where you're going to fall. I understand that uncertainty is scary - but insisting that a guy get sterilized - come on? As if you could actually force him to do that any way - more than likely you're going to push your daughter away.
 

Emily65Roses

New member
I'm somewhere in the middle on this one. It's hard to really take a side when I don't actually know these people. Sometimes in-laws are inclined to make things worse than they actually are because it's their child and their child's life that they're talking about. In other words, maybe this guy isn't as bad as you think/say he is. But then, he also could be. So there's no real way to tell. But I have to agree with Michelle on at least point A - it's not your life. And D too. They are adults, if they choose to take that route, that's their decision. But to even suggest it to them is kind of gross, in my opinion. Not your place.

<blockquote>Quote
<hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>Anonymous</b></i>
the potential that we as grandparents may, by design and their choice, outlive our grandchildren. That SUCKS!<hr></blockquote>
Not necessarily. The current CF average is 35. And it's certainly possible, I don't pretend to know everything. But as grandparents, you're not nearly as likely to outlive a CF child than your daughter and her fiancee would be.

<blockquote>Quote
<hr>We don't want to make our daughter hate us, but honestly feel like we have a real problem with a lackadasial approach to this situation (which they both have). Since this is definitely all new to us, how should we nudge them into genetic testing? Our daughter has a trust account with significant $$$'s in it and we were considering threatening to stop applying annual deposits unless they are both tested, and if carriers, that fiance' be sterilized. If indeed they are both carriers, we do not consider a 25% chance of CF acceptable odds (sorry, that's truly how we feel).<hr></blockquote>
This is your decision, of course, as it's your money that you're putting into her trust fund. However, having children is their decision, and if they feel a 1 in 4 chance is worth taking, then that's something they can do. You can't force them to think one way or another just because you want the best odds at a 100% healthy child. In fact, the way you sound is almost like you won't accept any grandchild that isn't healthy. Of course, you want healthy kids and grandkids, for their own happiness. But how pushy you're being makes it sound like if they have a kid and it has CF, that you'll neglect the child claiming and "I told you it'd have CF!!!" Even if they have a child and it's is imperfect in some manner.... it'll still be your grandhild. And if you avoid the CF scare, there's nothing saying the child won't have Down's or whatever other congenital defects you can think of. You need to square with the fact that your grandchild, no matter what you do, may not be perfect.
 

JazzysMom

New member
Initially I was highly offended by a few things. Not your concern about the CF, but your solutions such as sterilization. He is not a dog that should be neutered to help control the pet population. If every couple that both were CF gene carriers had 100% chance with each pregnancy of having CF then I could understand being SOOOOOO pushy about the issue. I dont know how old your daughter & her finance are. I dont know how responsible as a whole (not just financially) they are nor do I really know how educate they want to be or might already be about CF. As a women who has butted heads with her Mom over CF, a man & having a baby. I am telling you to find a mutual solution. The more you push the harder she will push back. You cant change what they are going to do. You can help them by becoming educated & helping them be so also. Your statement about your financial involvement should they have a child with CF is something my Mom would have said. You assume that you would have to handle it. Why is that? I dont know if you mean to sound so cold hearted, but you sure do. Just a thought also......even tho there is family history of CF, it doesnt gaurantee CF. If they got past the CF & ran into another genetic obstacle that could be just as expensive; would you have the same feelings?
 

anonymous

New member
Sterlization? Um...did anyone else not get offended by that remark? Maybe we should have sterilized your parents as to have not produced such sub human thinking neanderthals...

Ok sorry, i was just a little upset. But seriously, if you were my parents and you threatened to take my money away unless i got genetically tested, and then told that you wanted my husband or me sterilized....I would not have anything to do with you for the rest of my life.
 

anonymous

New member
Sounds to me like you don't like your daughters fiance' and are just using CF and an excuse to get him out of her life. I'm sure if you liked the guy you wouldn't be trying to drive him away just because he has a family history of CF. If it truely is that you don't like him, and you feel he is not right for your daughter, use that as the reason to threaten taking $$ away!
 
I

IG

Guest
Agreed with anonymous @ 7:33 p.m. and many others.

I would have to add, that if you are in fact trustee/advisor over the trust account for her and use that power to threaten her income [expected income through trust account funding] I believe it is illegal. I'm not certain about it, but I wouldn't doubt that it is. On top of that, if your daughter has any sense whatsoever, if you did that to her, I would if I were her, sue your a**. That's just me though.

On another not your daughter is her own person, it's none of your business, get your nose out of it unless they specifically ask for your advice/opinions.

As for the fiance..
He's not a mutt that was dragged off the streets, do not treat him as one.
 

TCNJcystic

New member
I'm 19. Having CF has actually been a great way to live. My parents have told me that through my life I've taught them so much about their own lives that they wouldn't change the past if they could (that is certainly not to say they wouldn't give an arm and a leg to cure me now.) The idea is that a CF child could turn out to be a blessing to your daughter. Consider that.

And on the not so nice side...sterilization? Are you serious? You're going to pay to have a man sterilized? You're actually going to put your money out on the table, in exchange for having a man sterilized? You're considering actually taking part of the family budget and putting it into the sterilization of a man your daughter loves? whoa.
 

rose4cale

New member
Here's a thought...

Instead of paying to have him 'sterilized'...(offensive), maybe you could pay for the invitro type procedure that would help reduce the risk of a CF conception. And possibly reduce the risk of making your daughter mad at you. This is considering they are even carriers. Trying to look on the bright side here... Because yes, my kids, CF or not, are the biggest blessing ever. And CF has taught me to be an even better parent!
 
Top