Can I vent?? Don't read if you are easily offended

anonymous

New member
I find it hard to believe the reason most people stayed was because they wanted to use the circumstance as an excuse to remain the underdog. How stupid ! What an insult !

I wasn't trying to convince you staying was the best decision. Tell me how people, with no money, no transportation, no help from the government could get far enough away from the storm in 2 days. Since you think it was so easy to get out- I would like to know how you would get out, with a family, with no money or transportation.

I guess we have to agree to disagree. No matter what the reson for being in La or MS when the storm, I don't think blame should be put on the people who went through this.


Have No Balls
 

Emily65Roses

New member
"I was thinking the same thing about insurance companies paying for fertility treatments. Maybe that was "mother natures" way of helping to cleanse itself of CF."

This doesn't really work, because if you would notice... new CF mutations are popping up all the time. We could wipe out the current CFers and new ones would still be born.
 

Mockingbird

New member
<blockquote>Quote<br><hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>Emily65Roses</b></i><br>"I was thinking the same thing about insurance companies paying for fertility treatments. Maybe that was "mother natures" way of helping to cleanse itself of CF."

This doesn't really work, because if you would notice... new CF mutations are popping up all the time. We could wipe out the current CFers and new ones would still be born.<hr></blockquote>

Ha ha, then with my twisted logic, cfers are invincible! We should form an army and take over the world!
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
Have No Balls,

My plan would be to hit the streets and ask for help to get out. I'd try and hitch a ride, ask my church for assistance, or just plain and simple beg for money to leave town. I think in two days you could scrape up enough money for a bus ticket to higher ground. I see people begging for money all the time and for the most part people are pretty generous. I know that if I was heading out of town and saw a mother and her baby that needed a ride or a bus ticket, I'd help.

I wasn't saying that the people that stayed were using these particular circustances to remain the underdog. It was just a general statement regarding their long term situation. Also I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't resort to personal attacks like, "How stupid!", as I have refrained from them myself and, as we both know, that's what get's these threads locked and people really pi$$ed off.

Yes, we'll agree to disagree.
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
Careful Mockingbird, someone may turn you over to the G-man like they did WinAce <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif" border="0">
 

julie

New member
Jennifer, I OWE YOU A HUGE APOLOGY. In the moment when I was typing that last post, I grouped everyone from that site into one pile. You did profusely thank me, and I do remember talking to you about getting your user name fixed for this site.... I am very very sorry that I made that general statement, when you are right, you did tell me how much you appreciated it. YOu have also "had my back" on that other CF2 site a few times (not in a bad way, but just stated that I recommended something, or I helped you, or "ask julie" sort of thing). I am very sorry that I grouped you in and I hope you can forgive me for that. I would be insulted if someone did to me, what I did to you so I hope that you can forgive it.

<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>I don't believe insurance should pay for fertility treatments. But, I don't have a say, so fertility is paid for and people make money by scamming the system. But I also know there are people who need the help and deserve the help. <hr></blockquote> Sure you have a say, lobby for it just like I lobby for coverage. and even though I am one who is awaiting a fertility treatment (NOT paid for by insurance), I sure wish insurance would pay for it. I also have to agree that mother nature may have intended males with CF to be infertile to stop this CF cycle. It is very possible and probably very likely. Does that change me wanting a baby with my husband-NO. Is there a 100% guarantee that our child will not have CF, or some form of the CF mutation??? Absolutely, there are NO certainties in life, bur as far as I have been tested, our child should not have CF. I know the risks and they aren't very high for our particular situation, but I have still researched them. I agree with your and KC's statement though.

Steve, I somewhat believe what you posted about religion and such. I grew up a very religious person and in all honesty, I am really on the fence now with what I believe and don't believe (there are so many different versions of things that happened, didn't happen...) but I still believe in God. Some others do, some others don't. I didn't really think about the "mother nature" thing in depth like you stated it (If we believe that God kept his promise, then we accept the disaster as nothing more than that, a terrible disaster. If we accept that god broke his promise, then this is the wrong forum for this discussion), I was just thinking about it more in the sense of, "I believe everything happens for a reason". And I still believe that it happened for a reason, whatever that reason is is probably individual to me-not to many others seem to share my opinion, but it remains the same despite that fact.

<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>no offense Julie but didn't you just slightly bash anon. him/her by just saying that they have a 'warped sense of the word'???, and addressing them in the first place? it seems like you want to talk everything to death, i mean come on this is an internet forum WHO CARES. someone was just trying to settle this place down a little.... xt<hr></blockquote> What anon. are you talking about?? If it is someone on this site, I believe I do recall stating that I believe they had a warped sense of the world to post what they did. Again, it's just my opinion. Maybe I do want to talk everything to death, I started this thread didn't I? TO TALK, RIGHT? So if you don't like it, don't read and don't post on this topic. Nobody is forcing you to, but please don't come complaining about what is being said within this thread. Don't like=don't read, don't like=don't post.
VERY SIMPLE.


<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>hey just a thought- maybe god was cleaning up the 500 + unproductive ppl with CF....sure glad i'm in new york. <hr></blockquote> Just as long as these words don't get put in my mouth. That isn't really a nice thing to say, but I believe you are being scarcastic. Most CFers I have met are the MOST productive people under the circumstances with which they live (meds, treatments, hospitalizations, complications, transplants....). I already clairified what I meant when I said unproductive, and it was clearly NOT refering to anyone with CF or anone who has a medical problem and can not work (or otherwise) because of a medical reason. There are things in life out of our control.

<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>about the unproductive people...our country doesn't do much to help them become productive, does it?. it may be better for them to keep receiving government help and not work than to work 80 hours a week and end up with less money than if they didn't work. poverty is a viscious cycle, just like drug abuse, physical/mental abuse, etc. <hr></blockquote> OUr country does a lot to help them become productive. It's abuse of the system that keeps the problems going. It's the fact that people have more luxuries in prision than most people have in their homes. My husband can't get a free education, I can't get a free education, Most people can't get a free education, but those in prision can. And repeat offenders, I won't even go there. Death row, why do we have 20 year waits on death row? It seems like a gross misuse of money to me. Some may argue that's playing God, fine, believe that. I believe in an eye for an eye sort of thing. I have done wrong in my life, and I don't think I have been punished to the fullest every time. I think I have gotten away with a lot, and then sometimes I think I have paid for more than I deserved. I think that things might be a little bit better if we were to be consistent with punishments. I believe that's where about 80% of the problem lies. People are given a slap on the hand and turned back into the streets, to make the same gross error again, get the same slap on the wrist and are let go again. These were the thoughts I was having in my head when I posted what I did on the other CF site. People use and abuse the system, get welfare, food stamps, free medical- because they keep having kids, because they can't hold a job, because they are too addicted to drugs to work, because they are too lazy to work..... the list goes on. And it leaves less resources for those who truely need it, like children with CF whos families are barely making it due to the costs of meds (most people on this site have been there) adults with CF who are trying to go to school or who can't work enough to make ends meet, or families where childre/adults have CP, or spina bifida or other problems. There are many people who really NEED the assistance but can't get it.

I'll stop there, I am very passionate about quite a few issues in case anybody hasn't noticed.....
 
J

jacobus

Guest
<blockquote>Quote<br><hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>CFHockeyMom</b></i><br>

. It's under water now like nature intended it to be. Just leave it that way.<hr></blockquote>

Don't let the Dutch hear you talking like that. You know that 90% of the Netherlands (all the major cities) is below sea level?
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
Just to lighten things up a bit...

<i>There are only two things I hate; those who are intolerant of other people's cultures........and the Dutch</i> - Nigel Powers from Austin Powers in Goldmember

Of course I don't really hate the Dutch but I think of that line whenever someone mentions them.
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>OUr country does a lot to help them become productive. It's abuse of the system that keeps the problems going. It's the fact that people have more luxuries in prision than most people have in their homes. My husband can't get a free education, I can't get a free education, Most people can't get a free education, but those in prision can. And repeat offenders, I won't even go there. Death row, why do we have 20 year waits on death row? It seems like a gross misuse of money to me. Some may argue that's playing God, fine, believe that. I believe in an eye for an eye sort of thing. I have done wrong in my life, and I don't think I have been punished to the fullest every time. I think I have gotten away with a lot, and then sometimes I think I have paid for more than I deserved. I think that things might be a little bit better if we were to be consistent with punishments. I believe that's where about 80% of the problem lies. People are given a slap on the hand and turned back into the streets, to make the same gross error again, get the same slap on the wrist and are let go again. These were the thoughts I was having in my head when I posted what I did on the other CF site. People use and abuse the system, get welfare, food stamps, free medical- because they keep having kids, because they can't hold a job, because they are too addicted to drugs to work, because they are too lazy to work..... the list goes on. And it leaves less resources for those who truely need it, like children with CF whos families are barely making it due to the costs of meds (most people on this site have been there) adults with CF who are trying to go to school or who can't work enough to make ends meet, or families where childre/adults have CP, or spina bifida or other problems. There are many people who really NEED the assistance but can't get it.<hr></blockquote>

You go girl! I agree 100%

I think people are lathcing on to your use of the word "unproductive"; maybe "non-contributing member of society" would have been more PC <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif" border="0">
 
J

jacobus

Guest
<blockquote>Quote<br><hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>julie</b></i><br>
<blockquote>Quote
<hr>hey just a thought- maybe god was cleaning up the 500 + unproductive ppl with CF....sure glad i'm in new york. <hr></blockquote> Just as long as these words don't get put in my mouth. That isn't really a nice thing to say, but I believe you are being scarcastic. Most CFers I have met are the MOST productive people under the circumstances with which they live (meds, treatments, hospitalizations, complications, transplants....). I already clairified what I meant when I said unproductive, and it was clearly NOT refering to anyone with CF or anone who has a medical problem and can not work (or otherwise) because of a medical reason. There are things in life out of our control.

...<hr></blockquote>

You feel that people with cf are productive because you have personal experience of what it is like to live with cf. Did you ever stop to think that all those 'lazy' people have problems of their own, which can be just as debilitating as cf. Your analogy is a little simplistic to my way of thinking. It's like those people who argue that all people who use (illegal) drugs should be locked up or worse, only to find out that their own child is a drug user, then they are very quick to change their tune. Sure, there are people who take drugs, rob, steal etc, but they are still people and more often than not there are very real reasons why those people are where they are. Would you be so quick to judge a homeless drug addict if you found out that they had cf and became homeless as a result of not having insurance? What if you then found out that that same person turned to illegal drugs after losing all hope and having nothing to live for? My point is that you never really know why another person is where they are. Hindsight and personal experience are wonderful insightful tools.
 

Lilith

New member
Julie,

I am just as passionate of a person as you are (read my blog if you don't believe me <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-smile.gif" border="0">) and I agree with you completely. No one should be bashing you for your opinions. I'm not one to talk, as I jump on a lot of people's cases, (especially when they make no sense!!) so I think you've been handling this much better than I could have.

As for Have No Balls, if you want to preach, do it somewhere else. This forum is about CF, not poverty issues. But if it will entertain you, I'll throw in my two cents -- most of the people that got stuck there in New Orleans were fools. Yes, I completely understand that some couldn't leave, but those that chose to stay were totally insane. And even then, what about the looters? You gonna try to defend them, too? Most of them were the 'poorest of the poor' as you put it. I can understand looting for food and water, but I saw people coming out with TV's, for crying out loud!! What the h***?!?! And then those that were shooting at the doctors and nurses and others trying to help?! I say let those individuals rot.

I think what we've seen here in the US is an insight into the true nature of most (not all, but most) human beings. Greedy, murderous dogs. I've seen animals behave better than what I saw on the news.

Okay, done my rant.

By the way, did you know that New Orleans didn't start out below sea level? It was just fine when it was originally founded, but the city grew around the original colony. Why they would continue to build below sea level is beyond me, but...oh well.
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
Well, illegal is illegal no matter how you got there. I think in America we tend to rationalize why someone may have done something illegal whether it be stealing, drug use, child molestation, etc... Yes, there are reasons why people commit illegal acts and maybe some of those reasons you consider just but the fact of the matter is we have laws and the reason someone breaks the law really doesn't matter.

<blockquote>Quote<br><hr>The necessity of the times, more than ever, calls for our utmost circumspection, deliberation, fortitude, and perseverance. Let us remember that `if we suffer tamely a lawless attack upon our liberty, we encourage it, and involve others in our doom.' it is a very serious consideration...that millions yet unborn may be the miserable sharers of the event.
- Samuel Adams <hr></blockquote>
 
J

jacobus

Guest
<blockquote>Quote
<hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>CFHockeyMom</b></i>
Well, illegal is illegal no matter how you got there. I think in America we tend to rationalize why someone may have done something illegal whether it be stealing, drug use, child molestation, etc... Yes, there are reasons why people commit illegal acts and maybe some of those reasons you consider just but the fact of the matter is we have laws and the reason someone breaks the law really doesn't matter.


<blockquote>Quote
<hr>The necessity of the times, more than ever, calls for our utmost circumspection, deliberation, fortitude, and perseverance. Let us remember that `if we suffer tamely a lawless attack upon our liberty, we encourage it, and involve others in our doom.' it is a very serious consideration...that millions yet unborn may be the miserable sharers of the event.

- Samuel Adams <hr></blockquote><hr></blockquote>

I disagree with you there. I strongly believe that the reason someone breaks the law is very important. As a society I would like to think that our goal is to reduce people commiting crimes. If we are to do this, then it is necessary to look at why people break certain laws. We should have an obligation to attempt to eliminate situations which foster lifestyles which are damaging to individuals and society generally.

People also need to be empowered to challenge laws that are causing more harm than good. Eg Germany 1940's. Laws can and often are wrong, we as citizens should not just blindly follow.
 

anonymous

New member
I'm sorry but I have to defind my site a little (CF2Chat)
I have been out of town during this whole thing. For some reason I feel that it was my fault it got to the point it did because people knew "the boss" wasnt around so they just go hay wire. Not all of course. Its just the way it feels. Now I know alot of people from that site are reading this I dont care. I do feel like I am at my wits ends alot of the times. Alot of times people do get the help they need...but there are those few and it can be a passer by (not you julie) or a regular member that seem to make things worse, take things farther than need be...or take advantage. I have also been one of those that thanked you (julie) for your help and information on here and on there. I even had told people to ask you(julie) about fertility. Anyway thats not my point of this. My point is alot of times people come and get the help and support they need. It seems like the old the site gets the more people join but the less things are posted and more people are just meeting on the site and then just IMing each other. Which is all good and great but if some of the cf related questions were posted it would help alot more people. and yes there are "groups" those from the cf site know this....if you deny it you are in the group. yes you are. I am not part of the group. here is where some of you (from cf2chat- my own group no less)are going to get ripped by me...you try to make me choose between my friends...you at the same time make me feel left out. but d*mned if i dont still try my hardest to make that place a good one. and what the h*ll happens....this (insert cuss words)!!! because of the dividedness (i know not a word) of the group people feel left out, ignored, as if just because they have a different opinion (harsh or not) is unwelcomed......so you maybe asking where is your defending coming in? well this site is the same d*mned way. i feel left out and ignored alot. and you say you cant argue there? you argue here all the freaking time about nonsense...sure some of it is good intellegent debates gone bad...but you good and well know (and you will argure with me on this) that alof of fights on here can be silly. at least on here they can be locked and still viewed. on my group since its hosted by msn i have no choice but to delte threads there is no way to just lock them. I also have assitant managers who help me on the site so if they see something before me or i am gone (like this time) they will delete threads when they think its necessary. i generally ;et bad threads go to long because i dont want to be a dictator. I have also meet alot of wonderful people there. life long friends (some who have passed)...I have met only one other person here just one thats wonderful (renee)...I meet candice through a friend in the same town we live in...and she is a great friend to me as well. one last thing. i have many friends...some who hate each other...and I hate it absolutely hate it when they get in arguments...it can tear a person apart.

ok sorry i stole you rant julie. i just really wanted to say please dont lump all the people at cf2chat into one category. that would be like saying everyone here is the same. and its just not true.

amanda
aka purplelungs
 

CFHockeyMom

New member
Jacobus, I see your point about acknowledging the issue as a means to rectifying the problem. However, once someone has broken the law you must be consistent and certain with your punishment. I don't believe our current "corrections" system is properly set up to "rehabilitate" the lawless. I also believe there are some that can't (or maybe just don't want to) be rehabilitated.

I'm not advocating following laws blindly, but I don't think that laws against drugs, looting, raping, and murdering are in question.
 
J

jacobus

Guest
<blockquote>Quote
<hr><i>Originally posted by: <b>CFHockeyMom</b></i>
Jacobus, I see your point about acknowledging the issue as a means to rectifying the problem. However, once someone has broken the law you must be consistent and certain with your punishment. I don't believe our current "corrections" system is properly set up to "rehabilitate" the lawless. I also believe there are some that can't (or maybe just don't want to) be rehabilitated.<hr></blockquote>

The rehabilitation system often causes more problems than it cures. There are certainly those who will continue to break the law whatever you do, but there is also a huge percentage of the prison population who are there for relatively minor offences. I think we have to question the wisdom of locking up non violent drug offenders for example with hardened serial offenders.
 

ReneeP

New member
<i>You feel that people with cf are productive because you have personal experience of what it is like to live with cf. Did you ever stop to think that all those 'lazy' people have problems of their own, which can be just as debilitating as cf. Your analogy is a little simplistic to my way of thinking. It's like those people who argue that all people who use (illegal) drugs should be locked up or worse, only to find out that their own child is a drug user, then they are very quick to change their tune. Sure, there are people who take drugs, rob, steal etc, but they are still people and more often than not there are very real reasons why those people are where they are. Would you be so quick to judge a homeless drug addict if you found out that they had cf and became homeless as a result of not having insurance? What if you then found out that that same person turned to illegal drugs after losing all hope and having nothing to live for? My point is that you never really know why another person is where they are. Hindsight and personal experience are wonderful insightful tools. </i>

Very wise words, Jacobus. I'm not trying to take sides here by any means. I admire you all for your own individual situations and I know that we all have our good and bad points. I just really think that Jacobus has a point that we should all consider. We do not know the situation of any of those people in New Orleans and should not judge a group of people like that. Until we are walking in someone else's shoes, we should not pretend to understand where someone else is coming from. I can honestly say I have been guilty of being judgemental of the way someone else was living and then found myself in a similar situation and had to bite my tongue. Every day brings new experiences and we learn new things...hopefully along with that we learn to understand that everyone has their own circumstances and we then become more tolerant.

I live in extreme south Texas. We recently had Hurricane Emily to deal with here. They didn't issue a mandatory evacuation but did give warnings and most of my neighbors boarded up their windows and stuff. Luckily our street was the only thing that flooded. It didn't come in our house. When you have that happen over and over again you do become immune to it. You don't take it so seriously anymore. The people in New Orleans have lived like that for years. Warning after warning. I can understand why some have that "it'll never happen to me" attitude. Then consider the people who may have wanted to leave but simply had no where to go. New Orleans is a high poverty city. Many people are poor and have no cars. I think about what if it were me in that situation. I have 5 kids, 2 with CF. Imagine me taking my kids, all the meds and stuff, and just taking off walking through the city. Where the hell would I go? To the Superdome?????? I'd rather have been in my own attic.

I have a great deal of family in New Orleans. My mother was from New Orleans and lived there until she married my father. I've been there many times. I have 4 uncles, 1 aunt, and more cousins than I can count who still live there. My aunt and 2 uncles left town. One of my uncles is a New Orleans police officer so is still there working. I have one uncle no one has heard from. We have no idea if he is dead or alive.

I could write a book about our government and what they should and shouldn't do in my opinion... In my opinion it's absolutely pathetic that those people in New Orleans lived in the conditions they did for so long...and some still are. It's uncalled for. Who gives a sh*t how poor they are....even if you want to call them fools... they still don't deserve what has happened to them. No one does. We can spend countless billions of dollars funding all sorts of stuff in other countries or even in Mars for that matter but we couldn't get to New Orleans to get people out???? Bullsh*t.... it just wasn't a priority because they are poor black people.... thats absolutely freaking wrong.

Yesterday I got a phone call from my baby brother who is a Marine. He has already served 3 tours of duty in Iraq. He has spent the majority of the last 3 years there. He has watched several of his friends die. He has been to hell and back. He got to come home in the spring and was told he would not have to go back to Iraq. His wife and him decided to have a baby since he would be home. (he missed the last baby being born as he was in Iraq). So she is now pregnant, due in January. He got a call this week telling him he has to go back to Iraq now for 6 more months...he leaves Oct 1. So he will miss this baby being born too. With all that is going on in New Orleans, Mississippi and Alabama, you'd think we would use our people to help our country but I suppose that's not the priority right now. It makes no sense to me. As you can probably tell, I'm not very "proud to be an American" at the moment. Sometimes I think our government is more concerned about appearances and what other countries think or need or want than what our citizens need or want. We will pay for the medical care of all the immigrants that come into the US but not for our own children who need it. My husband, 2 brothers, my best friend and several other relatives of mine have served in the millitary, so I'm not Anti-American...I'm just extremely frustrated at how things are being handled. And frustrated at my own situation of having to fight tooth and nail to get medical help for my children...
 

Emily65Roses

New member
Totally irrelevant and stupid... but I figured we could use a lighthearted comment, so here goes:

I'M A HURRICANE!!! <img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-tongue.gif" border="0">
 
Top